Written By: The Social Justice Gamer
CWs: Bigotry (Racism, Ableism, Sexism, Queerphobia)
People Involved: Pytyvo Gaming (Host) (https://pytyvogaming.wordpress.com/)
Synopsis: It’s #LevelUpDiversity week, in which we (along with many others) promote ethnic diversity in video games! This event is hosted by Pytyvo Gaming. They encourage video game designers to include ethnic and cultural diversity within their video games. Today’s post is about the “fear of diversity” many game developers seem to have.
Article: Once again, I’m writing from class. Probably not the best habit. Don’t expect images in this post for a while. Sorry! But hey, after tonight’s midterm, I might have time. Probably not.
Anyways, welcome to the last day of #LevelUpDiversity! It’s been a crazy week, but it’s been great. We need to focus on promoting ethnic and cultural diversity more often!
For this last post of the event, I decided to switch today’s and Friday’s post, since today’s post was supposed to require a bit more work but I’m extremely busy. Hopefully I can show you what I wanted to show today on Friday!
So, finally, to the point: today I’ll be talking about the “fear of diversity” game developers seem to have. While there is going to be a main focus on racial / cultural diversity, I’ll be talking about other forms of representation, too.
I’ve already done a similar post on why we should include people of disabilities in video games (https://socialjusticegamer.wordpress.com/2015/08/27/representing-people-with-disabilities/), and this will be in a similar format.
These past few days, I’ve been saying it’s obvious that we should be promoting ethnic and cultural diversity in video games. Yet, it’s also clear that this really isn’t happening. Well, admittedly, I think it’s starting to happen a lot more now compared to before, but that doesn’t excuse people from including diverse people in their games (“but other people are already doing it!”). Here, I’ll focus on some excuses I feel like game developers could / do make, and my responses to them.
“But other people are already including different forms of representation! Why should I?” Give me one good reason why you should not. Wrong time period for a certain race / ethnicity? Well, don’t tell me your world has magic or mythical creatures, then, because if it’s the wrong time period, then it’s also the wrong place for those things to be. Indeed, you can also include people with disabilities. Wrong place, and you need people of one culture or ethnicity only, as well as able-bodied people? Don’t tell me your world has no queer people! Your world may be limited, but that doesn’t mean diversity doesn’t exist.
“It isn’t important to my game / story!” But it’s important to your audience. Representation is always important to the audience. You don’t have to explicitly state where someone is from or what cultural background they grew up with. Just showing different types of people is already enough. Got a character who constantly gives the protagonist information? Make them a queer woman! Got a character who’s the protagonist’s best friend? Make them a PoC with a disability! Got a game? Include a diverse set of characters!
“But who cares?” Some people have no idea how many people care or just how much they care. But you must understand the impact of simple representation. When people see themselves in media, it makes them feel included and normal. Not that being “normal” is always good, but in this case, I mean that “normal” in the West is often seen as being white, cis, male, able-bodied, and straight. By defying any of those “norms”, people start to feel like they belong. People who can relate to your games are more likely to enjoy them. So: the audience cares, and you should, too.
“But isn’t it okay for all of my characters to be white? Is there anything wrong with that?” Being white is fine; only showing white people in media is not okay. There are more people of colour in North America than there are white people, and there are more people of colour in the world than there are white people. To constantly insist on only having white characters is harmful. For example, many people of African descent feel ostracized because they don’t experience the same things white people do; for example, they see that a “beautiful” or “sexy” person is a thin, white female, and feel they cannot be beautiful or sexy since they are not white. I often see Asian people trying to copy Western culture because that’s what they see, often hating their own bodies or the “generic black hair” we have. It’s harmful to only have white characters unless you have an extremely limited setting and plot where it makes sense. You can justify many stories as such, which is why I say that you should include other types of diversity. Not everyone is cis, straight, or able-bodied.
“I don’t mind including people of colour, but I don’t want to incorporate everyone’s culture every single time.” It’s not necessary, though it’s a nice touch. Westernizing people of colour can be harmful, but if you do it correctly, it can be very inclusive. Representing everyone as equals, with their own unique personalities and contributions, is extremely important if you don’t want to incorporate everyone’s culture. For example, you can have a Hispanic character without having to randomly incorporate Spanish phrases or culture throughout the game so long as you still represent them as a person, not just some character you input for diversity. White characters often get diverse personalities; refuse to reduce PoC to their stereotypes.
I hope this was a good read, despite the rush. I hope people enjoyed reading it and want to share it with others. While I focus on video games, this really goes for any sort of creation–a story, a show, an advertisement, etc. It’s important to have diversity no matter what you create. I hope this convinced you of that if you didn’t think that before.
And with this, #LevelUpDiversity comes to a close. I hope it went well! Make sure to check out Pytyvo Gaming, as well. They’re really awesome. Look out for another post on Friday!
Signing off,
SJG